1 has been influential but is now widely regarded as erroneous and long since refuted. It is not at all fanciful to trace one major source , perhaps the major source, of that verdict to Quine's comments in his paper "On Carnap's Views on Ontology" and in Word and Object.² For, although many others have commented unfavourably on Carnap's distinctions, most of these criticisms post-date Quine's comments and many of them are consciously influenced by Quine³. Nevertheless, despite this consensus I want to argue that Quine's criticisms leave Carnap's central points quite untouched." /> Carnap's internal and external questions - Bird Graham | sdvig press